Sculk AC vs FiveGuard
A cloud-configured anticheat with a long-running community and a browser panel with player lookup, trust score and a live map.
Facts checked 2026-11-13 from the sources below. We do not compare detection rates. “Not published” means we could not find it. The vendor site and docs returned access errors to automated checks, so several facts come from search summaries, resellers and rival comparison pages.
| Topic | Sculk AC | FiveGuard |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing model | Subscription in USD: Core $29, Pro $49, Network $129 per month; yearly saves two months. No lifetime plan. 14-day refund window. See pricing | EUR 45 per month or EUR 125 lifetime. A "Plus" add-on (about EUR 25 per month) is described by a competitor as unlocking monitoring. Resellers sell it separately. |
| Install and licensing | One folder and one line. Learning mode first, then a report, then enforcement on probation. A setup check command (sculk doctor) is documented. Sold as standalone software, not through Cfx escrow. | Server resource with a client half. Config is held in the cloud. One IP per licence; changing IP needs a reset through support. |
| Detection list | Every detection is public: what it checks, its confidence class, default, maximum action and known false-positive causes. See the catalogue | No public list found; the vendor documentation was not reachable when we checked. |
| Ban sharing | Sculk History is opt-in. It stores hashed identifiers, needs a 2-of-4 identifier match, and acts only on active, confirmed entries. The default for those entries is deny, which the owner can change. The player can see and dispute entries. Read how Sculk History works | Local bans with screenshot proof. Two rival vendors say it has no shared ban list. It offers ban-evasion protection and trust scores. |
| Evidence and review | Cases keep event traces and player timelines. Statistical and client signals never ban on their own. Players can appeal with the evidence summary the server chooses to show. | Screenshot proof on bans. Panel offers player lookup, trust score and monitoring. |
| Config controls | Presets, learning mode and per-detection settings. Sculky proposes a config change with its impact. Nothing applies until you confirm, an unconfirmed proposal expires after 15 minutes, and applied changes can be undone. Sculky cannot ban or unban. See Sculky | Config is edited in the cloud panel, with sub-users and temporary permissions. Its docs describe "Safe Events" for protecting events. |
| Privacy and data handling | Retention is published on the Data page. Raw IPs are kept 30 days. Screenshots and flight-recorder blobs are kept 30 days. The Data page is a draft pending legal review. See what we store | Not published |
| Support | Pro includes 4 h support; Network adds an onboarding call. Support channels are being finalised. | Discord tickets. A reseller also advertises live chat. |
When FiveGuard may suit you better
- You want a lifetime licence option (EUR 125) rather than a subscription.
- You want a vendor that says it has been on the market since 2022 and has a large Discord community (57,817 members on 2026-11-13).
- You want a live 2D map with watch zones and teleport mode in the panel.